Doomed to Fail: The Incredibly Loud History of Doom, Sludge, and Post-metal

Product Information

The way communities construct their “failures” is never innocent: tell me how you define a failure and I will tell you more about yourself. A comprehensive, thorough, and passionate view of doom, that music set to the pace of the downtrodden.

A good deal of the book is devoted to building the argument that the prime responsibility for learning rests with students, not teachers, and that the idea that learning is attributable to good teaching sets teachers up for failure. The book is still very band to band, but you're able to take context out of it and have a broad picture. It’s about [dis]comfort with horror, and in its original form emerged as a reaction against post-war austerity, industrial isolation and the general Shittiness of Living. The rest of the bands covered don’t seem to really fit, with the noise rock Harvey Milk, post-hardcore The Body, and goth/ethereal/darkwave Chelsea Wolfe. If you are the tormentor, you are not leading by example, with honest, open and direct communication.A bit more on the critical radar are women like Zola Jesus, Emma Ruth Rundle, Anna von Hausswolff, Lingua Ignota, Spellling and Circuit des Yeux, Its influence can arguably be heard in some of Billie Eilish’s music. So put the cards away – it turns out you were supposed to be playing blackjack anyway – and let’s build something that gives your content the home it really deserves.

I did enjoy reading Doomed to Fail despite my criticisms, and I especially appreciated learning a little more about bands that I'd either only heard about, or didn't know much of.Anselmi covers the bands and musicians that have impacted those styles most—Black Sabbath, Candlemass, Melvins, Eyehategod, Godflesh, Neurosis, Saint Vitus, and many others—while diving into the cultural doom that has spawned such music, from the bombing of Birmingham and hurricane devastation of New Orleans to glaring economic inequality, industrial alienation, climate change, and widespread addiction. Much of the book reads like a long list of American bands, which play heavy music, but can only be very loosely defined as Metal; while important European bands like, for example, Amenra are not even mentioned. If, on the other hand, the book is intended as a history of blues-derived, emotionally negative/pessimistic styles of music, then Doom does not belong – and the Metal-style layout is highly misleading. Happily, I found that Paul Shotton presented a practical and hopeful picture of what we can do to prepare for the upcoming challenges that we will need to overcome to build a better future for our children and grandchildren. Questions that ask how content can help us to: sell more products, be more competitive, attract and retain top talent, connect with key audiences, and even increase our valuation.